681
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The Orthodox Church and Commercial Fortune-Telling and Magic in Russia

Pages 420-442
Published online: 23 Nov 2011

Abstract

Based on field work in St Petersburg and supplemented by a range of other sources and material, the article examines the vibrant and visible market for commercial fortune-telling and magic in postsoviet Russia and its relationship with the Moscow Patriarchate. It opens with an estimate of the relative strength of belief in the occult and in Orthodoxy, noting that though large numbers claim to be Orthodox, many do not commit to a Christian life or even to the basic tenets of the Orthodox faith. Others mix Orthodox and heterodox religious attitudes eclectically. Belief in magic and fortune-telling is strongest among members of these two large groups, which indicates a magico-religious mindset that perceives their personal troubles as externally caused. Examining the placatory attitude of magic specialists to the Russian Orthodox Church, I argue that, given the overlap with services offered by the Church (rituals to cure alcoholism and addiction, for example), magic specialists are in direct competition with the Patriarchate. Combating their influence has been hampered by a series of factors. Teaching Orthodox believers to distinguish between magic and religion is made more difficult by the Patriarchate's own promotion of wonder-working sites and shrines. Furthermore, its campaign against occultism has until recently paid scant attention to everyday magic and fortune-telling, concentrating instead on external evil in the form of cults and sects. Where it did turn its attention in this direction, it tended to brand magic and fortune-telling as demonic, a characterisation likely to be effective only with those who believe in the devil. Recently, there are indications of a change of tack, but it is unclear how successful the new campaign will be.

Acknowledgment

I am grateful to the British Academy for funding my fieldwork and for the assistance of Dr Marina Hakkarainen, without whom interviews with informants would have been well-nigh impossible.

Notes

Magic specialists call themselves by various names, of which the commonest are koldun (sorcerer) which emphasises links (often spurious) with folk tradition and mag (magus) which emphasises western tradition.

The other area which has attracted a good deal of attention is the revival of elite occultism in Russia, largely excluding reference to its popular and commercial manifestations (Rosenthal, 1997 Rosenthal, B. G. 1997. “‘Political implications of the early twentieth-century occult revival’”. In The Occult in Russian and Soviet Culture, Edited by: Rosenthal, B. G. 379418. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.  [Google Scholar]; deNio Stephens, 1997 Denio Stephens, H. 1997. “‘The occult in Russia today’”. In The Occult in Russian and Soviet Culture, Edited by: Rosenthal, B. G. 35776. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.  [Google Scholar]; Brougher, 1997 Brougher, V. G. 1997. ‘The occult in Russian literature of the 1990s’. Russian Review, 56(1): 11024.  [Google Scholar]). More recently, in 2007, a conference was held in Berlin in 2007 devoted to ‘The Occult in Twentieth-Century Russia’. The organiser Professor Birgit Menzel is the author of the most recent and thoughtful discussion of the occult revival and its impact on Russian literature today (Menzel, 2007).

This argument does not appear in Lindquist's 2006 Lindquist, G. 2006. Conjuring Hope: Healing and Magic in Contemporary Russia, New York: Berghahn.  [Google Scholar] book and she may have changed her mind.

For comparative purposes the same article quotes the results of a similar survey of school leavers of various kinds from the Altai region. Results are analogous; if anything, the Altai children were slightly more superstitious than those in Krasnoyarsk (Nemirovsky and Manuil'sky, 1987 Nemirovsky, V. G. and Manuil'sky, M. A. 1987. ‘Fantasticheskiye predstavleniya kak element massovogo soznaniya’. Sotsiologicheskiye issledovaniya, 4: 7075.  [Google Scholar], p. 73).

For example, in a poll conducted for The Times by Ben Schott and Ipsos Mori in early October 2007, the percentage of ‘don't knows’ in reply to questions about fortune-telling was mainly very low (1–3 per cent), while for belief in ghosts, fate or premonitions figures were around 6 per cent (Schott, 2007 Schott, B. 2007. ‘Schott's almanac of belief’. The Times, 30 October [Google Scholar]).

In the earlier surveys, active churchgoers were also very superstitious, but this appears to be changing as the demographic shifts towards a younger and better educated congregation.

The debate about magico-religious practices within the Church is beyond the scope of this article.

Names of informants have been changed to preserve anonymity.

Kurayev has written on many subjects, and should not be seen simply as a conservative. In the 1990s he was not afraid of alienating Church fundamentalists by attacking the popular notions about witchcraft, prediction and the evil eye found in widely available booklets about locally venerated holy figures (Kurayev, 1999 Kurayev, A. 1999. Okkul'tizm v pravoslavii, Moscow: Blagovest.  [Google Scholar], pp. 174–310). As a result he is hated by some conservatives in the Church.

As public interest in psychic distance healing declined, the centre changed its name to Dushepopechitel'sky Tsentr imeni svyatogo pravednogo Ioanna Kronshtadtskogo and its focus onto drug addicts and alcoholics.

The group that runs the site is connected to other sites devoted to suicide, love and marriage, death of a loved one and the pain of parting.

Log in via your institution

Log in to Taylor & Francis Online

PDF download + Online access

  • 48 hours access to article PDF & online version
  • Article PDF can be downloaded
  • Article PDF can be printed
EUR 39.00 Add to cart

Issue Purchase

  • 30 days online access to complete issue
  • Article PDFs can be downloaded
  • Article PDFs can be printed
EUR 397.00 Add to cart

* Local tax will be added as applicable
 

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.