Advanced Search

Journal of Applied Statistics

Volume 35, Issue 6, 2008

Comparison of designs for the three-fold nested random model

Comparison of designs for the three-fold nested random model

DOI:
10.1080/02664760801924079
Byoung Cheol Junga, André I. Khurib & Juneyoung Leec*

pages 701-715

Available online: 19 May 2008

Abstract

The quality of estimation of variance components depends on the design used as well as on the unknown values of the variance components. In this article, three designs are compared, namely, the balanced, staggered, and inverted nested designs for the three-fold nested random model. The comparison is based on the so-called quantile dispersion graphs using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and maximum likelihood (ML) estimates of the variance components. It is demonstrated that the staggered nested design gives more stable estimates of the variance component for the highest nesting factor than the balanced design. The reverse, however, is true in case of lower nested factors. A comparison between ANOVA and ML estimation of the variance components is also made using each of the aforementioned designs.

Keywords

 

Details

  • Citation information:
  • Available online: 19 May 2008

Author affiliations

  • a Department of Statistics, University of Seoul, Seoul, Korea
  • b Department of Statistics, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA;
  • c Department of Biostatistics, Korea University, Seoul, Korea

Librarians

Taylor & Francis Group